Blog
How our understanding of context informs our understanding of nurse suicide; and why we need change.
There are 30 million nurses world-wide and the NHS, the largest employer in Europe, employs more women than any other organisation. It is also the principal employer of nurses of whom, 89% are women and one in four are from the global ethnic majority. Yet, the majority of suicide research and policy is gender- and colour-blind.
by Dr Ruth Riley
There are 30 million nurses world-wide and the NHS, the largest employer in Europe, employs more women than any other organisation. It is also the principal employer of nurses of whom, 89% are women and one in four are from the global ethnic majority. Yet, the majority of suicide research and policy is gender- and colour-blind.
The suicide rate among women nurses is 23% higher than women in other occupational groups.
These numbers are more than just statistics but speak of human stories of distress and suffering in women nurses across continents. Yet their voices, experiences, and stories are largely unaccounted for in dominant suicidology approaches and suicide prevention policies.
High suicide rates in women nurses have been documented for over 20 years in the UK and in other high-income countries too. Yet workplace practices, policies and research have failed to address the realities and contexts of nurses’ lives.
Current approaches and why they are failing women nurses
Deaths by suicide are often what we see or hear about but hidden beneath the surface are the diverse contexts that contribute to distress and suicidality. Our studies will argue that mainstream research approaches are not only gender- and colour-blind, but also focus on individual-level characteristics and the mental health of individual nurses and rely on methods which fail to account for wider contexts.
In North America, there is a trend which advocates screening for mental illness in nurses which may further label and individualise women’s (and others’) distress. This may compound stigma and increase shame, leading to the concealment and non-disclosure of feelings and distress and presenteeism, particularly in healthcare cultures which lack compassionate leadership and psychological safety.
Why we need to revision our understanding of distress and suicidality in women nurses
In contrast to these approaches, the ambition of our project is to address these under-researched contexts using critical suicidology which questions the mainstream approaches that locate ‘the problem’ within the individual. Our position argues that by individualising distress, attention is distracted from the political, social and economic contexts and systems within which nurses work and live. Solutions aimed at addressing these wider contexts and systemic problems – which include deep-rooted violence against women, both inside and outside the workplace, discrimination, poor working conditions, and other workplace injustices, are overlooked. Employing a feminist approach will enable us to better understand the patriarchal, social and structural systems which impact women nurses, nurses from the global majority, and othered communities. This is a timely project as we witness continued distress compounded by ongoing injustices, the pandemic and workforce and resource shortages.
Joining the dots – politics, mental health, and women.
Individualising distress and labelling distressed women as unwell goes hand in hand with current – neoliberal – political mindsets. For example, we are expected to maintain ‘good’ mental health despite changes in political and organisational systems which contribute to and sustain inequality and injustices for women and othered communities.
Messages about self-care, help-seeking and individual resilience are all examples of the drive toward individual responsibility for mental wellbeing. Therefore, the unjust systems that oppress and disadvantage women and others are excused any responsibility.
A feminist understanding of ‘mental illness’
Mainstream approaches to treating distress or ‘mental illness’ and the messages surrounding it are largely uncritical – relying on taken-for granted knowledge. Such approaches, as above, are underpinned by biological and medical models and are predominantly understood from a medical and male viewpoint. This poses a problem for women and for marginalized and minoritised communities.
In the UK and other high-income countries, women are three times more likely than men to be diagnosed with depression and anxiety. This proportion increases when women are also Black, lesbian and/or older. Historically, women are more likely to be institutionalized, in asylums and hospitals, receive psychosurgery, electroconvulsive therapy and psychotropic medication (particularly antidepressants), which can be accompanied by harmful side and withdrawal effects, including suicidal thoughts.
Medicalizing women’s distress and focusing on the individual is a form of institutionalized gaslighting, as their distress symptoms are reduced to a diagnosis yet their voices, experiences and the contexts contributing to their suffering are overlooked. In feminist research, women participants often resisted a medicalized diagnosis of depression as they attributed the cause of their misery to structural factors, including poverty and violence.
We argue that focusing on the personal, overlooks the political, and fails to hold to account those systems, structures and cultures which contribute to and sustain social, colonial and economic injustices, gender-based violence or the impact of work cultures and working conditions on women. This includes women nurses and ethnically diverse nurses and will apply to women working in other occupations, including doctors.
What is the ambition of this project?
This ground-breaking project has five different studies which will capture the diverse experiences and accounts of a range of women nurses and those from the global majority. We will also be capturing the views of the public, including friends and families of nurses to explore their understanding of what contributes to nurse distress and suicidality. In providing space and opportunities for new perspectives, we will gain a more nuanced understanding of relevant contexts while providing a voice and platform for under-represented nurses.
The project aims to transform research approaches, and trends in suicidology and significantly shift our understanding of the contexts that contribute to distress and suicidality within the nursing population. This research may also have direct implications for women working in other occupational groups. We wish to launch a more nuanced approach and debate about the contexts that impact women inside and outside the workplace.
The project will lead to societal benefits too by increasing public understanding of these issues. We want to change hearts and minds so that suicide is no longer viewed as an individual problem and its contexts are more widely understood.
I am proud to be leading this ambitious project with a passionate and experienced team, who include international experts, award-winning creative artists and, crucially, nurses themselves, who have shaped the project and research priorities. Over the next 5+ years, we will be working with nurses, for nurses, to radically revision our understanding of distress and suicidality within the nursing community.
